A worn or outdated bathtub can make your entire bathroom feel tired and uninviting. If or when you find yourself in this situation, you may start to debate whether you should refinish the existing tub or replace it altogether. Both options have their own advantages, but choosing the right solution depends on your budget, timeline, design goals, and environmental concerns. Moreover, there are many misconceptions surrounding the concept of bathtub refinishing. Many homeowners don’t realize its great potential and how it can help you achieve similar results at a fraction of the cost. But don’t stress. Here, we’ll cover the differences between bathtub refinishing and bathtub replacement to help you make the right choice for your home.
What Is Bathtub Refinishing?
Bathtub refinishing, also referred to as resurfacing or reglazing, restores the surface of an existing tub to a like-new condition. The process involves cleaning, repairing chips or cracks, applying a bonding agent, and finishing with a durable coating. It works well for various materials, including porcelain, fiberglass, acrylic, and cast iron. The key distinction in this technique is that it uses the existing structure as a foundation, and the refinishing process brings life back to your tub. Typically, this is the most cost-effective and efficient way to rejuvenate your bathroom without a full-scale renovation.
What Is Bathtub Replacement?
Bathtub replacement involves completely removing the old tub to install a brand-new one in its place. This process often requires demolition, plumbing adjustments, and retiling. While more expensive and time-consuming, it provides complete design flexibility. If you want to get rid of your bathtub or make it bigger, a replacement is usually the best way to go. You can change the tub’s overall size, style, and material, so it’s ideal for any major remodels.
Cost Comparison: Refinishing vs. Replacement
Cost is one of the most significant factors when deciding between refinishing and replacement. Refinishing typically costs between $400 and $500, with an additional $300 if surrounding tiles are included. In contrast, replacing a bathtub can range from $3,000 to $5,000 because it requires a more intensive approach. Refinishing offers a high-impact transformation at a fraction of the price for budget-conscious homeowners (or anyone who doesn’t want to spend thousands of dollars).
Time Commitment
Refinishing is also the clear winner if you’re looking for a fast solution. The entire process can be completed in one to two days, including curing time. In contrast, bathtub replacement can take one to two weeks, or even longer, due to the demolition and changes to plumbing typically required.
Durability and Lifespan
Both options offer impressive longevity when done correctly. A refinished bathtub can last 10 to 15 years with proper care, while a new bathtub can last 15 to 30 years, depending on the material. Gentle cleaning and avoiding abrasive products can help maintain a refinished tub’s appearance and extend its lifespan, making it a great option for all households.
Environmental Impact
Refinishing is eco-friendly as it involves reusing your existing tub, reducing landfill waste, and conserving resources needed to produce a new tub. Many refinishing products are also designed to be environmentally safe. In contrast, bathtub replacement generates more waste and requires new materials, increasing its environmental footprint. If sustainability is a priority, refinishing is the greener option.
Aesthetic and Design Flexibility
When it comes to design, refinishing allows you to customize the color and finish of your tub to fit your bathroom’s existing style. However, it doesn’t allow changes in the tub’s size or shape. Replacement offers complete design freedom and is usually better for homeowners seeking a total bathroom overhaul.
Which Option Should You Choose?
Ultimately, choosing between bathtub refinishing and replacement depends on your design goals. However, bathtub refinishing still offers a ton of options for customization and adjustments at a fraction of the cost. For expert advice and quality refinishing services, contact The Surface Doctors today. Our team of bathtub refinishing experts is here to help you achieve a stunning, updated bathroom that fits your vision. Contact us today to learn more.